Vapers Digest 13th April
Monday’s News at a glance:
The Impact of Prohibition on Health and Ethics ~ EU Tax Opposed ~ New Zealand Risks Oz-Style Crime ~ The CEO of Philip Morris International Walks Into a Tobacco Control Convention ~ Still Smoking, Still Failing: What This Study Reveals About a System Stuck in the Past ~ The Policy That Created the Problem It’s Now Investigating ~ What the Curves Conceal ~ From the Soapbox ~ Vaping, smoking and risk of early onset lung cancer ~ Interplay of Metals and Organics in E-Cigarette Aerosols Enhances the Production of Reactive Oxygen Species within Ultrafine Particles: Implications for Passive Vaping Exposures ~ Scrap the Ban, Keep the Controls: CAPHRA’s Message to Bangladesh ~ UC San Diego Gives Government Bans Credit For Ending The Vaping Fad ~ Nicotine Blamed for Lung Cancer: What a Clinician Survey in Eastern Europe & Central Asia Reveals ~ Italy Formally Submits Detailed Opinion to EU Obstructing Ireland’s Disposable Vape Ban ~ What France’s new tobacco research means for India’s evolving public health approach ~ Vaping cancer review sparks expert backlash over ‘deeply misleading’ claims ~ WHY ARE THE SAFER NICOTINE PRODUCTS GETTING BANNED?
Three From Dave Cross, Planet Of The Vapes
The Impact of Prohibition on Health and Ethics
The Global Forum on Nicotine (GFN26) team has announced the first keynote session and that the conference programme is now live for the event set to take place in Warsaw from 3-5 June. Organisers say that the programme will be continually updated online as they announce new speakers and that it is the best place to keep track of the GFN26 lineup.
EU Tax Opposed
The European Economic and Social Committee (EESC) draft opinion on the revision of the Tobacco Taxation Directive (TED) has met with support from consumers and experts. They are calling on the European Union to follow “a risk‑based taxation approach”, warning that high, poorly designed taxes can fuel black markets, undermine health goals and reduce legal tax revenues instead of cutting smoking.
New Zealand Risks Oz-Style Crime
The Coalition of Asia Pacific Tobacco Harm Reduction Advocates says that New Zealand is risking an Australia-style tobacco crime surge if it ignores the benefits of tobacco harm reduction. Australia has been experiencing gang-related fire-bombings and murder due to its de facto ban on legal vapes. The Coalition says that New Zealand will emulate Australia if it relies too heavily on restriction, high prices, and enforcement.
Three From Alan Gore
The CEO of Philip Morris International Walks Into a Tobacco Control Convention
There’s a moment, just before he steps through the doors, where the irony becomes almost too much to ignore. It lingers in that brief pause between outside and inside, between reputation and reinvention, between what this company was and what it now claims to be becoming. Inside, the banners read “End Smoking” and “A Smoke-Free Future.” Public health professionals fill the space, speaking a language that is firmly defined by prevention, cessation, and abstinence. Outside, standing briefly still, is the CEO of one of the largest tobacco companies in the world.
Still Smoking, Still Failing: What This Study Reveals About a System Stuck in the Past
The paper published in the Australasian Journal on Ageing presents itself as another careful contribution to the evidence base around smoking, health, and ageing. On the surface, it fits neatly into the broader public health narrative. Smoking remains harmful, cessation is difficult, vulnerable populations are disproportionately affected, and the system must continue refining its response. But when you read it closely, something else becomes clear. It is not just describing a problem. It is quietly exposing a system that is failing to solve it.
There is something quietly surreal about watching an inquiry into illicit tobacco unfold in Australia (AGAIN).
Not because illicit trade is new. It isn’t. Every country deals with some level of it. But because of the timing, the tone, and the careful framing of the problem now being examined.
What the Curves Conceal
Claudio Teixeira, Disobedient Margins
Rates have fallen, and cigarettes have moved out of the center of social life.
But tobacco control did not simply reduce smoking. It reorganized where smoking remains, concentrating it among those for whom quitting was never merely an individual choice.
Over the past several decades, few stories have been told with as much consensus as those of tobacco control. It runs through reports, treaties, and scientific papers as one of those rare victories public health likes to display without lowering its eyes: a widespread problem, deeply embedded in social life, gradually pushed to the margins until it seemed, at least on the surface, to be under control.

From the Soapbox
Devin LaSarre, Invariant
“It is hard to imagine a more stupid or more dangerous way of making decisions than by putting those decisions in the hands of people who pay no price for being wrong.” – Thomas Sowell
Analysis of the nicotine industry is well-served by a handful of maxims:
Next-gen products have augmented demand for nicotine
Relative cost profiles, both in monetary and health terms, foster a shift away from legacy categories and to these new products
Sensible regulation does not move in unison with innovation and consumer behavior
Vaping, smoking and risk of early onset lung cancer
Marisa A. Bittoni, David P. Carbone, Randall E. Harris, PubPeer
Gal Cohen comment accepted April 2026
This is one of a series of studies which compared a population of patients diagnosed with lung cancer to a matched case-control sample in a health care system in Ohio from 2013-2021. Incidence of e-cigarette use was compared between the two samples to see if there was an association with lung cancer. The lung cancer sample was taken from a population that was hospital-diagnosed and treated for cancer, while the case-control sample data was taken from the community setting during annual checkups.
Interplay of Metals and Organics in E-Cigarette Aerosols Enhances the Production of Reactive Oxygen Species within Ultrafine Particles: Implications for Passive Vaping Exposures
Wonsik Woo, Linhui Tian, Charles Diamond, Michael Lum, Timothy Lyons, Ying-Hsuan Lin, PubPeer
Roberto A. Sussman comment accepted April 2026
The authors examine laboratory produced aging of vaping aerosol produced by ozonolysis of terpene flavoring chemicals producing organic hydroperoxides, which decompose to form radicals upon aqueous dissolution. These processes enhance metal abundance and production of ultra-fine particles (UFPs) mediated by redox metals with a likely role of Fenton-like reactions. The authors also suggest potential negative implications from the inhalation of aged aerosol and their deposition in the lungs.

Scrap the Ban, Keep the Controls: CAPHRA’s Message to Bangladesh
Coalition of Asia Pacific Tobacco Harm Reduction Advocates, Global Newswire
CAPHRA supports Bangladesh’s review of its sweeping 2025 ban on vaping and other emerging nicotine products as a chance to replace rushed prohibition with smarter, enforceable tobacco harm reduction policy.
Reports that lawmakers are considering removing the ban on the production and sale of e-cigarettes should be seen as a course correction, not a retreat from public health. CAPHRA says Bangladesh can protect young people, maintain strong tobacco controls, and still avoid the mistake of banning lower-risk alternatives for adults who smoke.
UC San Diego Gives Government Bans Credit For Ending The Vaping Fad
Hank Campbell, Science 2.0
During the Obama administration, the credibility of the US Centers for Disease Control went into serious decline. Though it only became evident to most how incompetent career government bureaucrats were when COVID-19 hit – they denied it was a pandemic and said the President was being xenophobic for wanting to ban travel from China(1) – those of us inside the system saw that they were long not equipped to help with much at all. If you need six weeks to tell the public lettuce has E. coli, basically five weeks after people had eaten the lettuce, you are not a public health agency, you are just a government job works program.
Nicotine Blamed for Lung Cancer: What a Clinician Survey in Eastern Europe & Central Asia Reveals
Giorgi Mzhavanadze, European Scientist
When nicotine is blamed for lung cancer: what a clinician survey in Eastern Europe and Central Asia reveals about evidence translation
In a fast‑moving scientific debate, the weakest link is often not the evidence itself, but how that evidence reaches the point of care. A new baseline survey of clinicians and other health professionals in three Eastern Europe and Central Asia (EECA) countries suggests that, when it comes to nicotine and alternative nicotine products, risk understanding may be drifting from the distinctions that underpin modern tobacco control.
Italy Formally Submits Detailed Opinion to EU Obstructing Ireland’s Disposable Vape Ban
2Firsts
Italy’s Ministry of Enterprises and Made in Italy has submitted a detailed opinion against Ireland’s proposed “Public Health (Single Use Vapes) Bill 2025.” Italy argued that the comprehensive ban on disposable vapes lacks scientific evidence, violates the EU principle of the free movement of goods, and conflicts with the existing Tobacco Products Directive.
What France’s new tobacco research means for India’s evolving public health approach
The Times Of India
The French ministry of health has updated its official position on smokeless tobacco products following a recent report by the French Agency for Food Safety, Environment, and Occupational Health (ANSES). After reviewing more than 2,500 scientific publications, the agency concluded that while smokeless tobacco products are not risk-free, their harm levels are considerably lower than those of conventional cigarettes. For India, this development merits careful consideration within the country’s broader public health context.
Vaping cancer review sparks expert backlash over ‘deeply misleading’ claims
Ali Anderson, Clearing The Air
A new paper suggesting links between vaping and cancer has triggered strong criticism from leading experts, who warn its conclusions are “misleading” and risk confusing the public.
The study, published in Carcinogenesis, examined potential cancer risks associated with vape use, drawing on laboratory, animal and biomarker evidence.
But in a coordinated response, scientists said the review overreaches, lacks methodological rigour, and fails to reflect the current state of evidence.
Global Forum on Nicotine
Is the EU ignoring the most effective tool to end smoking? In this episode of GFN News, Joanna Junak sits down with renowned physician and public health researcher Dr. Konstantinos Farsalinos to discuss his latest review on nicotine pouches. As smoking rates across the globe remain a primary public health concern, Dr. Farsalinos argues that we are overlooking a “promising harm-reduction option” that could save millions of lives.
A look back at how things have moved on or otherwise…
Ban on smoking substitute snus upheld
New Nicotine Alliance
The European Union’s ban on the smoking substitute snus can be upheld according to the European Court of Justice’s advocate general. In his preliminary opinion, ahead of the court’s decision this summer, Henrik Saugmandsgaard said that while the evidence for the ban was not clear cut, the European Parliament had the right to impose the ban in 1992. He said that he did not find that the ban was “manifestly inappropriate”. (The opinionwas released this morning.)
Snus Ban: Let’s Leave The EU..
Dick Puddlecote
As I reported in January, the UK government went in to bat for the EU in favour of upholding the ban on snus everywhere but Sweden when it was challenged in the ECJ.
Overwhelming isn’t the word, snus has just about been given a clean bill of health in every aspect. A Lancet review spoke of no evidence of harm from long-term use of snus ”for any health outcome” (p 1364).
Visit Nicotine Science & Policy for more News from around the World





