Vapers Digest 19th June

Friday’s News at a glance:
Families Benefits from Vape Switch ~ Speak Up, Vapers ~ Parliament Matters ~ ACS Welcomes Plans for Dodgy Shops ~ The International Covenant Betrayal: How Australia’s Vaping Ban Undermines the Right to Health ~ Journal Entry – What Is Within My Control Today? ~ Media Watch: The Trends Wire Muddies the Waters on Pouches ~ Setback in fight against smoking as European Parliament rejects landmark nicotine ruling ~ Study claiming vaping weakens lung cancer benefits challenged by its own peer reviewer ~ Fruit-flavoured vapes lead UK stop-smoking services as quit rates beat other support ~ Netherlands throws out disposable vapes ban plan ~ Tobacco Harm Reduction IS Harm Reduction ~ Closing the Harm Reduction Gap: EMPOWERing People Who Smoke ~ An interview with Derek Yach about his recent report: “Nicotine 2030” ~ South Africa’s Next Generation of Nicotine Addicts? Before We Accept That Narrative, Let’s Examine the Evidence. ~ Growing Calls to Integrate Tobacco Harm Reduction Into Drug Services ~ Challenging the Obsession About Youth Uptake, Data Show That US Tobacco Policy Is Focusing on the Wrong Issue ~ The Effect of Online Sales Bans on E‑Cigarette Use ~ European Parliament rejects Commission’s plan to hike taxes on nicotine products ~ European Parliament rejects EU tobacco tax report
Four From Dave Cross, Planet Of The Vapes
Families Benefits from Vape Switch
According to a new five-country survey highlighted by the Coalition of Asia Pacific Tobacco Harm Reduction Advocates (CAPHRA), families feel the benefits when smokers switch from cigarettes to vapes. CAPHRA says the findings matter because smoking cessation is often treated as an individual issue, when in reality the effects are felt across the home.
Speak Up, Vapers
Citizens, health professionals, scientists and consumers across Europe have a rare chance to make their voices heard in crucial European Commission consultations that could shape the future of smoking reduction across the continent, according to Smoke Free Sweden. Consumer group ETHRA cautions that the process for one of them is “impossible to answer for anyone with an understanding of the differences in risk between different tobacco and nicotine products.”
Parliament Matters
This week’s vape related trip to Westminster is all about James McMurdock, the inquisitive independent MP for South Basildon and East Thurrock. James wanted to know about the impact of illegal vapes, the prevention of their sale, how many have been seized and what their impacts are on people’s health. Sharon Hodgson was the lucky government minister charged with providing the responses.
ACS Welcomes Plans for Dodgy Shops
The Association of Convenience Stores has described the government’s plans to target “dodgy vape shops” and rogue traders as a win for responsible retailers. It welcomed what it described as “a significant victory in the battle against the illicit trade”, as the Government announced 12-month closure orders for businesses selling illicit vape and other products.
Two From Alan Gore
The International Covenant Betrayal: How Australia’s
Vaping Ban Undermines the Right to Health
Human rights are often spoken of in lofty and inspiring terms. Governments invoke them when discussing equality, dignity, healthcare, justice and the protection of vulnerable people. Australia has long presented itself as a nation committed to these ideals, proudly signing international treaties and declaring its support for the protection of fundamental human rights. These commitments are regularly cited in political speeches and international forums as evidence of Australia’s moral leadership and its respect for the rules-based international order. Yet there is an extraordinary contradiction at the heart of Australia’s tobacco and nicotine policy that receives almost no public attention.
Journal Entry – What Is Within My Control Today?
One of the strange things about writing about tobacco harm reduction is that it has taught me as much about myself as it has about public policy.There are days when I become frustrated by how slowly institutions change. I read another headline that oversimplifies the evidence, another political statement that ignores nuance, or another debate where ideology seems to matter more than data. It is easy to feel as though progress is impossible when the same arguments repeat themselves year after year.
Media Watch: The Trends Wire Muddies the Waters on Pouches
The Daily Pouch
There is a seemingly never-ending supply of articles that incuriously promote World Health Organisation (WHO) sensationalism on nicotine pouches. Many of them are funded by various public health charities and NGOs; others do it just for fun. None of them quite understands the issues.
Take this piece by The Trends Wire, an online publication that I had never heard of until today. Titled WHO Warns 40 Million Children Are Already Addicted — and 160 Countries Have No Nicotine Pouch Rules, the alarmist tone is designed to grab attention rather than elucidate.
Setback in fight against smoking as European Parliament rejects landmark nicotine ruling
Smoke Free Sweden
International health experts say Europe’s lawmakers have today prioritised politics over public health by voting against a report that would have formally recognised that different nicotine products carry different levels of health risk.
The European Parliament’s rejection of the report on the revision of EU tobacco taxation rules is a significant setback for efforts to reduce smoking-related disease across the continent.
Three From Clearing The Air
Study claiming vaping weakens lung cancer benefits challenged by its own peer reviewer
Ali Anderson
A new study suggesting vapes may weaken the lung cancer benefits of quitting smoking was challenged during peer review over serious methodological concerns.
The study, published in Nature Medicine on June 8, analysed health data from more than 4.5 million adults in South Korea with a history of smoking.
It reported that former smokers who used vapes after quitting had higher risks of lung cancer incidence and lung cancer-specific death than former smokers who did not vape.
Fruit-flavoured vapes lead UK stop-smoking services as quit rates beat other support
Ali Anderson
A new study found vaping products are now widely used by UK Stop Smoking Services.
In the detailed results, 27 out of 28 local authorities reported providing vapes to help smokers quit.
Every service supplying vapes offered flavoured products, with fruit offered by all and reported as the most popular or most frequently supplied flavour.
Among services reporting quit rates for both approaches, vaping-supported quit rates averaged 61.5 per cent, compared with 56.2 per cent for other support.
Netherlands throws out disposable vapes ban plan
Tim Hong
The Dutch government has rejected plans for a national ban on disposable vapes, warning that such a move would be legally uncertain and should instead be dealt with at EU level.
The decision means the Netherlands will not push ahead with new national restrictions on single-use products including disposable vapes and cigarette filters, despite environmental concerns over waste, fires and litter.
Ministers said a domestic ban on disposable vapes could conflict with the European Tobacco Products Directive. Instead, the cabinet said an “EU-wide ban seems the most promising option” and that the Netherlands will argue for action in Brussels.
Tobacco Harm Reduction IS Harm Reduction
Sip Murray, Skip’s Corner – Let’s Talk!
This is Part 3 of my series, “Tobacco Harm Reduction IS Harm Reduction.”
In Part 1, I looked at several major public health organizations and asked an important question: Why do our compassionate public health principles sometimes seem to pause when the subject shifts to nicotine?
In Part 2, I turned my focus to the University of Iowa Health Care, examining its public messaging after reading an analysis by public health researcher Jason Semprini. What I found was a familiar, heartbreaking disconnect. The university beautifully champions patient-centered care, active stigma reduction, and the vital role of peer support when dealing with general substance use.
Lindsay Reese, Marina A. Murphy, Kim Murray, Cureus
Abstract
Global tobacco control efforts, influenced substantially by the World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control and the MPOWER package, have lowered smoking prevalence in some populations but have failed to address the lived realities of the people who continue to smoke. These individuals increasingly come from communities marked by socioeconomic disadvantage, lower educational attainment, and limited access to healthcare, contexts where structural constraints, chronic stress, and reduced opportunity shape tobacco use far more powerfully than individual “choice.” Yet tobacco control frameworks continue to prioritize abstinence-only strategies, punitive measures, and restrictive regulatory environments that rarely reflect the perspectives or needs of the people most affected. Countries are praised for adopting increasingly restrictive policies, with little attention given to the actual reductions in smoking rates.
An interview with Derek Yach about his recent report: “Nicotine 2030”
Jean-François Etter, Nicotine, tobacco and smoking cessation
I would like to extend my sincere thanks to Derek Yach for taking the time to answer a few questions about the report he recently published, titled: “Nicotine 2030”. Both the report and his responses below compel us to broaden the scope of our thinking about the situation. The interview discusses synthetic nicotine, how life insurance can help reduce smoking-related mortality, the WHO, the tobacco and nicotine industries, the illicit market, the situation in low- and middle-income countries, cytisine, differences of opinion among experts in the field, and future prospects. It’s food for thought, enjoy the read!
South Africa’s Next Generation of Nicotine Addicts?
Before We Accept That Narrative, Let’s Examine the Evidence.
Kurt Yeo, THR Global
The headline is alarming. The reality is more complicated. While youth vaping deserves attention, the evidence behind claims of a “new generation of nicotine addicts” is far less certain than readers are led to believe. Missing data, selective sampling and South Africa’s broader public health realities paint a very different picture.
A recent article claims South Africa has “The nicotine Wild West: How SA birthed the next generation of nicotine addicts”.
It is a powerful headline.
It is also exactly the kind of claim that demands careful scrutiny.
Nobody should misunderstand my position.
Growing Calls to Integrate Tobacco Harm Reduction Into Drug Services
Kiran Sidhu, Filter
“It’s time drug treatment and harm reduction services got involved with tobacco harm reduction,” Gerry Stimson told the audience.
Stimson, a public health social scientist and emeritus professor at Imperial College London, was speaking at the Global Forum on Nicotine (GFN) in Warsaw, Poland, in early June. He emphasized the extremely high prevalence of tobacco smoking, and related harms, among people who use banned drugs.
Challenging the Obsession About Youth Uptake,
Data Show That US Tobacco Policy Is Focusing on the Wrong Issue
Diane Caruana, Vaping Post
For years, tobacco harm reduction experts have highlighted that nicotine policy should follow one simple principle: people smoke for nicotine, but they die from combustion. Yet, repeating a pattern unfortunately witnessed all across the globe, in the United States, regulators are increasingly focusing on restricting nicotine itself rather than accelerating the decline of cigarette smoking. Recently, there have been ongoing legal battles over flavoured vapes and states piling on taxes for smoke-free products, on the premise that youth uptake must be discouraged.
The Effect of Online Sales Bans on E‑Cigarette Use
Charles J. Courtemanche, Dhaval M. Dave, Daniel L. Dench, Shubhsri Rajendra, Jooyoung Kim, & Joseph J. Sabia, Cato Institute
The tobacco product landscape has dramatically changed in the past two decades due to electronic nicotine delivery systems (ENDS), particularly electronic cigarettes (e‑cigarettes). Since their introduction to the US market in 2007, e‑cigarettes have surged in popularity, particularly among young people. In 2014, they surpassed conventional cigarettes as the most widely used tobacco product among consumers under the age of 18. From 2017 to 2018, past-month e‑cigarette use nearly doubled among high school students, from 11.7 to 20.8 percent, and increased among middle school students from 3.3 to 4.9 percent over the same period. This rapid increase prompted the US surgeon general to declare youth vaping a national epidemic.
European Parliament rejects Commission’s plan to hike taxes on nicotine products
World Vapers’ Alliance
The European Parliament rejected the European Commission’s plan to establish minimum excise tax rates on vapes, nicotine pouches and heat-not-burn products. In two sequential votes on the revision of the Tobacco Excise Directive (TED), MEPs first rejected the ECON committee’s amended report, and then rejected the Commission’s proposal outright.
The ECON report authored by Czech MEP Tomáš Kubín, which proposed lower excise duties than the Commission’s original proposal and enshrined a “less harm, lower tax” principle was rejected by the narrowest of margins: 308 in favour, 320 against. The Commission’s original proposal, put to the vote immediately after, was rejected by an overwhelming margin of 439 votes to 181.
European Parliament rejects EU tobacco tax report
Tobacco Journal International
The European Parliament has rejected a key report on the revision of the EU Tobacco Taxation Directive (TTD), dealing a setback to plans for higher excise duties and broader taxation of next generation nicotine products. According to parliamentary results, the report was defeated by 439 votes to 181, with 38 abstentions, preventing lawmakers from adopting a common position on the proposed reform.
On this day…2017!
A look back at how things have moved on or otherwise…
Avoiding bureaucratic destruction
Of the US vaping market – proposals for a new approach by FDA
Clive Bates, The Counterfactual
Can the impending near-complete destruction of the U.S. vaping market be averted? A group of public health experts believes it can – though time is running out. Led by Iowa Attorney General Tom Miller (@AGIowa) they have written to the new Commissioner of the Food and Drug Administration, Dr Scott Gottlieb (@SGottliebFDA) with proposals and supporting material. The focus is on what can be done by the FDA itself, without Congress amending the Tobacco Control Act.
Do As You Are Told!
Paul Barnes, Facts Do Matter
Y’see, in April this year one particular anti-smoking group kicked the bucket. It became an ex-anti-smoking group. Most folk I know celebrated the demise of Healthier Futures, which followed on from the demise of Smokefree South West – both groups tried a last ditch re-brand in order to stay current with “public health epidemics” – with Fresh NE taking ownership of the Healthier Futures IP.
Visit Nicotine Science & Policy for more News from around the World









