Vapers Digest 24th November
Monday’s News at a glance:
Pouch Considerations – EU Members Spike COP Plot – Emily Banks at COP11: A Masterclass in Selective Science and Moral Panic – COP11, Media Spin, and the Manufactured Narrative of “Industry Interference” – COP11 Day 4: First Cracks in the ideological wall – COP11: EU Commission and Denmark Continue Push of Backdoor Vape Ban – COP11: Increased concerns over EU approval of smoke-free nicotine ban – ”100,000 jobs at risk” – Outrage over Sweden’s COP11 cop-out on harm reduction to ‘health fascists’ – The WHO’s Anti-Vaping Blind Spot Is Undermining Its Own Tobacco Goals – The WHO is a billion dollars in the red – The Conference That Wasn’t Supposed to Happen – Revealed: Secret push for total nicotine prohibition at COP11 – Defying member states and risking over one million EU jobs – Bureaucrats and busybodies: COP11’s “experts” SA can do without – WHO Woes & Pre-Budget Jitters – Evidence summary: The health effects of nicotine – Can vaping help wean people off cigarettes? Anti-smoking advocates are sharply split – Smoke-Free Youth, Stalled Adults: From 30 Years of Progress to the Next Frontier in Tobacco Policy – US FDA panel to weigh bid to market nicotine pouches as lower-risk than cigarettes – Communications ConCOPtions – Belgium plans sweeping vape flavour ban amid policy gridlock – Youth vape risk measures may be overstated, suggests new study – Virginia Defends Ban on Unauthorized Flavored E-Cigarettes in Federal Court – Africa’s tobacco crisis demands smoke-free solutions – Crackdown on fake vapes to include digital QR tags – COP Live Day Five #COP11 – COP Live Day Six #COP11 – GOOD COP 2.0 | Day 5 of 5 | RegWatch (LIVE) – TPA’s Good COP 2.0 (Day 5) – WHAT’S THE TRUTH ABOUT HARM REDUCTION IN NIGERIA? – GFN.TV Interviews | TOBACCO SCORECARD | Real Progress Tobacco Control Fails to Admit
Two From Dave Cross, Planet of The Vapes
Pouch Considerations
David Phillips from Alternix:
Many smokers are considering the newer forms of safer nicotine products and even vapers are considering nicotine pouches for when they are in situations where they can’t vape. David Phillips from Alternix has shared five things to consider when switching from cigarettes to nicotine pouches.
EU Members Spike COP Plot
A group of countries within the European Union, spearheaded by Sweden, Greece and Italy, have opposed the EU’s plan to help push for bans on safer nicotine products at the World Health Organization’s tobacco control summit, COP 11. EU Ambassadors instead agreed a text that promoted increased levels of regulation, and the word “ban” has been omitted.
Two From Alan Gor, Australia – Let’s Improve Vaping Education (A.L.I.V.E.)
Emily Banks at COP11: A Masterclass in Selective Science and Moral Panic
If COP11 needed a demonstration of how ideology can hollow out science, Professor Emily Banks delivered it. Her speech, framed as “current evidence on the risks of e-cigarettes”, was less a scientific briefing and more an emotional appeal crafted to reinforce the WHO’s pre-determined anti-nicotine narrative. What she presented wasn’t a balanced assessment of evidence, but a political position dressed up as epidemiology.
The headline alone tells you everything you need to know about the state of tobacco control journalism today:
It’s dramatic, emotional, and completely unfalsifiable. It also sets the tone for an article that works overtime to defend a failing system, using the same recycled talking points we have heard for years from Bloomberg-funded NGOs: no progress is ever their fault; all disagreement is interference; all dissent is industry-driven.
Two From World Vapers’ Alliance
Alberto Hernandez
It is day 4 of COP. After 104 country delegate statements, the policy discussions are underway, and the first leak has emerged. The EU Commission and Denmark are pushing for bans on vaping and pouches, despite the EU’s joint position rejecting such measures. This undermines the democratic process, ignores evidence and the principles of tobacco harm reduction. It aligns Denmark and the Commission with countries like Brazil, which submitted proposals to the WHO calling for a complete rejection of harm reduction.
COP11: EU Commission and Denmark Continue Push of Backdoor Vape Ban
According to reports from Euractiv, multiple EU countries have accused the European Commission and the Danish COP Presidency of attempting to push for bans on vaping and nicotine pouches “through the back door” during COP11 — despite a prior EU agreement not to support global prohibition of less harmful alternatives.
The pressure reportedly centres around Article 4.5 of the COP11 agenda, which encourages countries to adopt stricter regulations or bans on tobacco and novel nicotine products.
COP11: Increased concerns over EU approval of smoke-free nicotine ban – ”100,000 jobs at risk”
Stefan Mathisson, Vejpkollen
The EU delegation representing the Union at COP11 may advocate for a ban on smokeless nicotine products at the COP11 meeting on the Tobacco Convention in Geneva. This is despite the fact that, after weeks of negotiations, it was agreed not to do so. Now Italian media are warning of the consequences. “The novel nicotine products sector employs 100,000 people in Italy. All the talk of a ban completely lacks a socio-economic impact assessment.” writes the newspaper la Reppublica.
Outrage over Sweden’s COP11 cop-out on harm reduction to ‘health fascists’
SnusForumet
Just days after Snusforumet reported on growing concerns that Sweden might weaken its long-standing harm-reduction stance at WHO COP11, a Swedish MEP has slammed the government’s actions in Geneva as bowing to “health fascists” Swedish MEP Charlie Weimers has issued a sharp warning on X, accusing Swedish officials on-site of failing to defend Sweden’s “red lines” in the face of efforts by the EU that could lead to a ban on nicotine pouches.
The WHO’s Anti-Vaping Blind Spot Is Undermining Its Own Tobacco Goals
Christina Smith, Town Hall
The World Health Organization’s (WHO) own newly-released global report leaves little room for denial: safer nicotine alternatives are catching on worldwide, and that’s bad news for the prohibitionists. After surveying 195 countries and finally measuring global e-cigarette use, the WHO’s data make one thing clear—vaping is displacing smoking. Yet instead of embracing a shift that could save millions of lives, the WHO is heading into its Conference of the Parties (COP) 11 still doubling down on counterproductive anti-vaping policies that defy both evidence and common sense.
Christopher Snowdon, Velvet Glove Iron Fist
Among the many lowlights at this year’s WHO anti-nicotine shindig was the Framework Convention Alliance giving New Zealand the Dirty Ashtray award for repealing the ludicrous generational tobacco ban while giving Mexico the Orchid Award for making a speech about how ghastly the tobacco industry is. New Zealand’s smoking rate has been falling fast and is now one of the lowest in the world. Mexico’s smoking rate has been rising.

The Conference That Wasn’t Supposed to Happen
Claudio Teixeira, Disobedient Margins
In Geneva, where silence skirts the status of an official language and the corridors of multilateral forums operate under a code of opacity, something broke protocol this European autumn.
Less than two kilometers apart, but separated by worldviews that neither speak to nor tolerate each other, two gatherings disputed the same symbolic ground: the map of global health and the right to narrate it.
Revealed: Secret push for total nicotine prohibition at COP11 – Defying member states and risking over one million EU jobs
Colin Stevens, EUReporter
A leaked EU negotiation document from the COP11 WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) meeting in Geneva has exposed a covert attempt by the European Commission (DG SANTE) and the Danish EU Council Presidency to force through a sweeping, unprecedented prohibition on all novel nicotine products.
Bureaucrats and busybodies: COP11’s “experts” SA can do without
Martin van Staden, Daily Friend
This week the richest country on Earth is hosting the biennial banquet-ball of bankers, bureaucrats, and busybodies.
The Eleventh Session of the Conference of the Parties (COP11) to the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) is unfolding in Geneva, with the usual band of self-styled public health experts again gathering to dictate public policy for billions worldwide.
It is a party we as ordinary people were not invited to – and never will be.
WHO Woes & Pre-Budget Jitters
Christopher Snowdon, Institute of Economic Affairs
Last week saw the World Health Organisation hold its biennial anti-nicotine conference in Geneva. With the unwieldy title of the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) Conference of the Parties, it used to be an anti-tobacco meeting but the WHO is now explicitly at war with what it calls the “nicotine industry”. There is no economic or moral justification for using state coercion to pursue a “nicotine-free world”, and there are strong health arguments for allowing low-risk nicotine products to displace cigarettes. What we are seeing is turbo-charged mission creep and a classic example of Not Invented Here Syndrome.
Evidence summary: The health effects of nicotine
Action on Smoking and Health (UK)
This briefing summarises the current evidence on the health effects of nicotine and outlines the key implications for policymaking. It has been produced by ASH with input from Prof Ann McNeill, King’s College London; Prof Jamie Brown and Prof Lion Shahab, University College London; Prof Nick Hopkinson and Prof Alan Boobis, Imperial College London; Prof Sanjay Agrawal, Chair, Royal College of Physicians Tobacco Advisory Group; Prof Jacob George, University of Dundee; Dr Jasmine Khouja, University of Bath; and Dr Andy McEwen, Chief Executive, National Centre for Smoking Cessation and Training.
Can vaping help wean people off cigarettes? Anti-smoking advocates are sharply split
Gabrielle Emanuel, Arundathi Nair, NPR
To vape or not to vape?
That is the question sparking a heated debate this week in Geneva where over 1,400 delegates have gathered to discuss the World Health Organization’s tobacco control treaty and what they call “the tobacco epidemic.”
Smoke-Free Youth, Stalled Adults: From 30 Years of Progress to the Next Frontier in Tobacco Policy
Jeffrey S. Smith, RStreet
Over the past 30 years, cigarette smoking among high school–aged youth in the United States has fallen to historic lows. In the early 1990s, more than one in four high school students smoked, and cigarettes were still widely marketed and socially accepted. Since then, policy interventions, public health campaigns, and regulatory action have driven shifts in social norms and a dramatic reversal of once-common behavior.
US FDA panel to weigh bid to market nicotine pouches as lower-risk than cigarettes
Reuters
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration said on Friday that it will convene a panel of experts on January 22, 2026, to review an request by Swedish Match USA, a unit of Philip Morris International (PM.N), opens new tab, to market its ZYN nicotine pouches as lower-risk alternatives to cigarettes. The advisory committee will examine modified-risk applications for 20 ZYN products, each sold in 3-mg and 6-mg strengths.

Communications ConCOPtions
THE FIREBREAK
After this week’s UN Conference of the Parties (COP) conferences on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and Tobacco Control (WHO’s FCTC) demonstrated the wasteful ineffectiveness of these global travelling circuses, the two events closed with their prewritten press releases celebrating their enormous success. But how on earth can the UN continue to pretend that their failed global policy system is anything but ridiculous? Strangely, these events need to fail in order to meet the multitude of their success factors.
Two From Ali Anderson, Clearing The Air
Belgium plans sweeping vape flavour ban amid policy gridlock
Belgium’s federal government is preparing a sweeping ban on all vape flavours except tobacco, a move Health Minister Frank Vandenbroucke says is necessary to stem rising youth vaping.
But the announcement lands as Vandenbroucke and his party face mounting questions about stalled policymaking elsewhere – including their inability, after a full year, to pass a federal budget. The City of Brussels, also governed by his party, is in the same position.
Youth vape risk measures may be overstated, suggests new study
Only 51.9 per cent of youth who said they might vape went on to try it within four years.
28.8 per cent of youth who said they definitely wouldn’t vape tried it anyway.
The measure did not reliably identify which young people would vape.
Findings “question the public health relevance of susceptibility as a proxy for use” and raise questions about aggressive vape regulations.
Virginia Defends Ban on Unauthorized Flavored E-Cigarettes in Federal Court
Tobacco Reporter
Virginia is pushing back against a challenge to its statewide ban on unauthorized flavored e-cigarettes, arguing in federal court that the restriction is both legally sound and critical to protecting youth from nicotine addiction. The law prohibits the sale of any flavored vaping product that has not been specifically authorized by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration—effectively barring nearly all flavored e-cigarettes currently on the market.
Africa’s tobacco crisis demands smoke-free solutions
Dr Vivianne Manyeki, Business Daily
Africa stands at a turning point in its public health journey. As smoking rates rise, the policy response remains trapped in outdated ideologies that prioritise prohibition over science. Global tobacco control efforts still focus on abstinence, yet ignore a critical, evidence-based tool in the fight against tobacco-related disease, smoke-free alternatives.
The science is clear: the real danger of tobacco lies in combustion. Burning tobacco releases thousands of toxic chemicals that cause cancer, heart disease, and respiratory illness.
Crackdown on fake vapes to include digital QR tags
Marc Ashdown, Lucy Hooker, BBC
Rogue traders selling illegal vapes could face £10,000 fines and a potential prison sentence under new rules designed to tackle the booming business in unlicensed e-cigarettes, the government has said.
A raft of new measures is set to be announced in the Budget on Wednesday, including new powers for the Border Force and the tax authority, HMRC.
Two From COPWatch
COP Live Day Five #COP11
Welcome back to Copwatch’s COP Live reporting on FCTCCOP11. Here we bring you our observations and impressions on day five.
COP11 agenda progress
The penultimate day for COP11, there will be urgency to get agreement on the outstanding agenda items today. The Journal shows that progress is slow on items 4.3 (environment), 4.4 (Articles 9 and 10) and 4.5 (the Secretariat’s attempt to co-opt harm reduction). We are pleased that Parties are taking the time to discuss such important issues thoroughly. Of course, GATC and ASH would not agree, their bulletins from today show considerable frustration that there is any debate.
COP Live Day Six #COP11
An update from us at COPWATCH, on the final day of COP11.
COP business
The Journal shows that discussions are ongoing today for items 4.4 and 4.5. As we have been reporting this week, those are both highly controversial. Will COP manage to reach consensus on those today?
GOOD COP 2.0 | Day 5 of 5 | RegWatch (LIVE)
Regulator Watch
DAY #5 | Live from Geneva, Switzerland – RegWatch special coverage of the Taxpayers Protection Alliance’s Good COP 2.0, the tobacco harm reduction counter-conference to the World Health Organization’s COP 11.
TPA’s Good COP 2.0 (Day 5)
Taxpayers Protection Alliance
WHAT’S THE TRUTH ABOUT HARM REDUCTION IN NIGERIA?
Global Forum on Nicotine
Nigeria is experiencing increasing health impacts from smoking, and experts argue that harm reduction—not prohibition—is key to saving lives. In this GFN News episode, Joanna Junak interviews Uche Olatunji and Yusuf Adebisi on the major barriers to tobacco harm reduction in Nigeria, including widespread misinformation about nicotine and a lack of educational resources. They discuss community outreach, science-based alternatives, and the critical roles of universities and the media in shifting public perception. Learn how evidence-based harm-reduction strategies can help Nigerians make safer, informed decisions.
GFN.TV Interviews | TOBACCO SCORECARD | Real Progress Tobacco Control Fails to Admit
Global Forum on Nicotine
Former Iowa Attorney General Tom Miller—America’s longest-serving AG and a principal architect of the Master Settlement Agreement—joins GFN.TV with a clear warning: the U.S. is making extraordinary progress against combustible tobacco, yet the public isn’t hearing about it. Smoking has collapsed to historic lows, youth vaping has fallen 70% since 2019, and millions of adults have shifted to far safer non-combustible nicotine products. By any honest measure, it’s one of the most significant public-health successes in decades. So why isn’t tobacco control talking about it?
A look back at how things have moved on or otherwise…
Speak Up To Save Flavours In The UK!!
Guest Post: Mark Oates – ECigClick
As Rishi Sunak ponders whether or not to ban vaping flavours, new evidence from across the pond should give him pause for thought.
This is because Yale University research across 375 US localities and seven states, which have applied flavour restrictions to impact youth vaping, found for every flavoured vape pod not sold – 15 more cigarettes were in its place.
Sweden’s Experience Lessons For Africa
World Vapers’ Alliance
Sweden’s harm reduction strategy to combat smoking-related deaths and improve public health is an inspiring model that has saved millions of lives. Sweden’s result towards achieving a smoke-free society is a success story and an exemplary model for countries around the world, especially in Africa, to adopt in their ongoing efforts towards reducing the health impact of smoking.
Visit Nicotine Science & Policy for more News from around the World






