Vapers Digest 25th September

Friday’s News at a glance:
SGF Reveals Crime Concerns ~ Parliament Matters ~ Taoiseach is Wrong on the Science ~ The Question Nobody Asks After a Vape Ban ~ The People Missing From Australia’s Tobacco-Control Victory ~ Electronic Cigarette Use and Risk of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease ~ E-Cigarettes Join Smoking Cessation Toolkit ~ Vapers Who Never Smoked Show No Clear Excess Illness in an England Survey ~ U.S. Regulators Plan Major Move to Speed Authorizations of Vapes, Tobacco Pouches ~ Endgame to Failure: How the Zero-Tolerance Campaign Against Nicotine Will Backfire ~ ATF Joins Interagency Trade Fraud Task Force to Combat Illicit Vape and Tobacco Trafficking ~ New Poll: Trump Voters and Bipartisan Majority Support President Trump Introducing Real and Commonsense Vaping Reform ~ Stakeholders Without a Stake ~ Brief Submitted to Standing Senate Committee on Social Affairs, Science and Technology ~ Two Years Later: Where Is the Evidence Canada’s Nicotine Pouch Policy Is Working? ~ Teen Vaping Is Falling in Pennsylvania… So What Is the State Doing? ~ I Guess It’s Not “Elbows Up” for Government ~ Is Banning Nicotine Pouch Marketing at Over-18 Festivals Sensible Policy? ~ The Policy War on Smoke-Free Alternatives ~ Nicotine Pouches: Mark Carney Must Give Marjorie Michel Clear Direction ~ Amid Campaigns to Loosen Nicotine Pouch Rules, Canada’s Health Minister Responds ~ Vapes Could Be Seized from You in UK Under New Rules ~ Alberta Minister Says Ottawa’s Nicotine Pouch Regulations Abandon Rural Communities ~ VTA Launches Ad Campaign on Vaping Regs
Three From Dave Cross, Planet Of The Vapes
SGF Reveals Crime Concerns
The Scottish Grocers’ Federation (SGF) says that convenience store owners in Scotland fear that forcing vaping products behind shutters could further fuel illicit trade. A consultation into how products are packaged and displayed as part of the Tobacco and Vapes Act runs until October 2 and retailers and vapers are being urged to make their voices heard.
Parliament Matters
Hooray! It’s time to go to Parliament to hear solid and comprehensive answers from the government ministers currently running the country – and this week’s is the best ever! And connected, while you’re here, may I recommend The Invisible Man by H.G.Wells? Not that the government is descending into brutality like Well’s protagonist, more that answers from its ministers are as impossible to find.
Taoiseach is Wrong on the Science
Ireland’s Taoiseach (Irish PM) Micheál Martin has been accused of “dangerously misleading smokers” after claiming vapes are “nearly worse than cigarettes” and signalling support for an outright ban. His comments directly contradict the latest evidence from Cochrane, widely regarded as the gold standard for independent medical evidence.
Two From Alan Gor
The Question Nobody Asks After a Vape Ban
Every day we ask questions. Some are small. What should I have for dinner? Should I take this route home? Should I buy this or wait until next week? Others quietly shape the course of our lives. Should I change careers? How should I raise my children? What kind of person do I want to become? What will people remember me for? The quality of our lives is determined less by the answers we find than by the questions we choose to ask.
The People Missing From Australia’s Tobacco-Control Victory
Australia’s latest Illicit Drug Reporting System report is confronting. It describes a group of people living with risks that should never be minimised or pushed aside simply because one set of figures happens to strengthen an argument about tobacco policy.
Electronic Cigarette Use and Risk of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease
K. Farsalinos, MD, MPH, PhD, Science & Public Health
Researchers at the University of Kansas ran a 12-week pilot trial with 46 COPD patients who smoke and had no intention of quitting with approved methods. Everyone got a pod-based e-cigarette with 5% nicotine, in menthol or tobacco flavor, plus basic switching support. No control arm. No pharmacotherapy comparison. At week 12, there were two outcome groups:
E-Cigarettes Join Smoking Cessation Toolkit
Neil Skolnik, MD, Medscape
Today we are going to talk about a landmark recommendation that we can start using right away. The bottom line is that e-cigarettes work really well for smoking cessation, and we can immediately start including them in our recommendations for smoking cessation. Our discussion today is based on a special communication from a working group of the Treatment Research Network of the international Society for Research on Nicotine and Tobacco, and it has a strong evidence base.
Vapers Who Never Smoked Show No Clear Excess Illness in an England Survey
Coios
The study classified 7,625 adults in the 2022 Health Survey for England into six mutually exclusive nicotine-use groups and modelled seven self-reported condition groups and multimorbidity, adjusting for age, sex, ethnicity, deprivation, education, alcohol and physical activity. Odds of any condition were highest among dual users (aOR 2.35) and vapers with a smoking history (2.13), above exclusive smokers (1.87) and former smokers (1.44). Among current vapers who had never smoked the estimate was 1.24 (95% CI 0.58-2.63), and no disease-specific association in that group survived correction for multiple comparisons.
U.S. Regulators Plan Major Move to Speed Authorizations of Vapes, Tobacco Pouches
Liz Essley Whyte, Laura Cooper, The Wall Street Journal
The Trump administration is planning to smooth the way for more tobacco products such as flavored vapes to legally enter the market by changing the rules to speed up the authorization process, people familiar with the matter said.
Editor note, PDF version: [U.S. Regulators Plan Major Move to Speed Authorizations of Vapes, Tobacco Pouches ]
Endgame to Failure: How the Zero-Tolerance Campaign Against Nicotine Will Backfire
Ian Irvine, C2C Journal
Endgame” conjures up bracing notions of triumphal decisiveness. In chess, the endgame marks the winning player’s conclusive strategy for taking an opponent’s king and achieving victory. In the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Endgame was the final movie in a lengthy series about saving the galaxy from master villain Thanos. So when the influential Ontario Tobacco Research Unit (OTRU) recently released a report seeking to end smoking by 2035 – pointedly titled Canada’s Tobacco Endgame – it no doubt had a similar dramatic flourish in mind. Unfortunately, a close reading of the OTRU’s plan is more likely to bring to mind Samuel Beckett’s 1957 absurdist play of the same name.
ATF Joins Interagency Trade Fraud Task Force to Combat Illicit Vape and Tobacco Trafficking
ATF Press Office, Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives
The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives today announced it has joined the interagency Trade Fraud Task Force, strengthening federal efforts to stop illegal, mis-declared, and smuggled goods, such as illegally entered vapes and nicotine products, from entering U.S. commerce and funding organized crime.
New Poll: Trump Voters and Bipartisan Majority Support President Trump Introducing Real and Commonsense Vaping Reform
Vapor Technology Association (VTA)
The Vapor Technology Association (VTA) today released new survey data from pollster and former senior counselor to President Trump, Kellyanne Conway, revealing that all voters and President Trump’s voters overwhelmingly reject efforts to ban flavored vaping products and support dramatic, fundamental reform to the current FDA rules for vapor products.
Stakeholders Without a Stake
Clive Bates, The Counterfactual by Clive Bates
In the UK, we are currently enduring the consultation on a package of anti-vaping, anti-harm-reduction measures. These accompany the pointless and overhyped smoke-free generation measure, the fool’s gold at the heart of the new Tobacco and Vapes Act. You can read my take on this dreadful legislation here: Ten reasons to dislike the UK Tobacco and Vapes Bill.
Two From Maria Papaioannoy, Rights4Vapers
Brief Submitted to Standing Senate Committee on Social Affairs, Science and Technology
My name is Maria Papaioannoy, founder of Rights 4 Vapers. I have spent years advocating for people who smoke, people who vape and people trying to leave cigarettes behind. I know the Tobacco and Vaping Products Act, especially the “V”, extremely well. I have lived it, worked with it, argued about it and watched what happens when policies written in Ottawa hit people on the ground.
Two Years Later: Where Is the Evidence Canada’s Nicotine Pouch Policy Is Working?
Following comments by federal Health Minister Marjorie
Michel that she is not considering changes to Canada’s restrictions on nicotine pouches,
Rights4Vapers (R4V) says there is a more fundamental question that needs answering:What evidence does the federal government have that its current approach is achieving its
intended results?The restrictions Minister Michel is defending were introduced in August 2024 by then-Health
Minister Mark Holland. The Ministerial Order was intended to reduce the appeal of, access to
and recreational use of nicotine replacement therapies by young people, while maintaining
access for adults using them to quit smoking.
Teen Vaping Is Falling in Pennsylvania… So What Is the State Doing?
Roger Bate, Substack
Pennsylvania’s Department of Health has a webpage intended to help parents and teachers talk to children about vaping. That is a perfectly legitimate objective. Children who do not use nicotine should not begin.
But the page makes a striking factual claim: teen vaping is “skyrocketing.” Pennsylvania’s own data show precisely the opposite.
I Guess It’s Not “Elbows Up” for Government
The Nicotine Project
Last week, the newly formed Ontario Nicotine Action Table — ONAT — announced its big plan to tackle tobacco and nicotine use in Ontario. And they called it a “Made-in-Ontario Plan.” Great opportunity to capture the buy local vibe that is taking over Ontario and Canada!
Is Banning Nicotine Pouch Marketing at Over-18 Festivals Sensible Policy?
The Daily Pouch
The Journal.ie has raised the alarm over nicotine pouch marketing at Irish festivals. Spurred by the Irish Cancer Society’s claim that almost 700,000 festivalgoers were subjected to various pouch promotion efforts, the digital news website has added its voice to the calls to regulate the harm-reduction product. However, the situation is a bit more complex than the article might have you believe.
The Policy War on Smoke-Free Alternatives
Considerate Pouchers
Smoking remains the leading cause of preventable death worldwide. Yet, just as nicotine pouches are giving millions of adults a viable, smoke-free way to quit cigarettes, a coordinated regulatory push in the West is threatening to dismantle this option.
Pouches help people quit smoking and live healthier lives, but there are several threats to these products in the EU and the US. And defending the right to pouch matters for public health, now more than ever.
Nicotine Pouches: Mark Carney Must Give Marjorie Michel Clear Direction
I want my pouches, Newswire
I Want My Pouches is calling on Prime Minister Mark Carney to intervene directly in the nicotine pouch issue following comments by federal Health Minister Marjorie Michel, who said she is not considering easing restrictions that limit their sale to pharmacies.
For TJ Peric, founder of I Want My Pouches and a Royal Canadian Navy veteran, the Minister is on the wrong track, and the Prime Minister must now provide clear direction to his government.
Amid Campaigns to Loosen Nicotine Pouch Rules, Canada’s Health Minister Responds
Canadian Press, CTV News
Federal Health Minister Marjorie Michel says she’s not considering changes to regulations that restrict the sale of nicotine pouches, while tobacco control groups say the government needs to do more to tamp out the illicit market.
Health Canada regulates nicotine pouches as an aid to quit smoking and restricts their sales to adults. They are not allowed to be sold for recreational use and must be kept behind the counter at pharmacies.
Vapes Could Be Seized from You in UK Under New Rules
Neil Shaw, Cambridge News
Holidaymakers bringing vapes back to the UK from abroad could have them confiscated at the airport under a new rule that starts on Thursday, October 1. From the start of October, travellers arriving in England, Scotland, or Wales can only bring back 50ml of vape liquid without paying tax, the same as five standard 10ml bottles.
Alberta Minister Says Ottawa’s Nicotine Pouch Regulations Abandon Rural Communities
Will Vasseur, Western Standard
Alberta’s Minister of Red Tape Reduction, Dale Nally, says Ottawa’s restrictions governing the sale of nicotine pouches have created a barrier for rural Albertans looking to quit smoking, as the federal health minister claims she is not considering loosening regulations.
VTA Launches Ad Campaign on Vaping Regs
Tobacco Reporter
The Vapor Technology Association (VTA) launched a seven-figure cable, broadcast, and digital advertising campaign urging President Donald Trump and Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to replace the FDA’s current Premarket Tobacco Product Application (PMTA) framework with what the trade group describes as clear, science-based guidance for vapor products. The campaign is running on Fox News programming, Truth Social, and X. VTA said the campaign cites a poll showing 71% support for replacing the current PMTA rules with scientific guidelines.
On this day…2017!
A look back at how things have moved on or otherwise…
Advertising code at fault
Over e-cigarette public health ad ban – Clive Bates
So newspaper reports suggest we have the ridiculous situation of the UK Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) banning adverts for vaping that are part of a public health quit smoking campaign, ‘Stoptober’. The Sun reports UP IN SMOKE: Anti-smoking adverts by Cancer Research see charity in row over barmy Brussels rules that would BAN them.
Regulate In Haste, Repent At Leisure
Dick Puddlecote
The last couple of days have been a story of regulators regulating for the hell of it instead of using their powers responsibly with the public in mind. Yesterday we saw Transport for London take a Thor-sized hammer to crack the peanut of procedural problems with Uber.
Visit Nicotine Science & Policy for more News from around the World









