Vapers Digest 4th October
Wednesday’s News at a glance:
THR Summit calls for alignment of communication to fight against misinformation ~ Harm reduction policies can result in RM1.1bil annual savings, says think tank ~ Response to Emeritus Professor Simon Chapman AO, “Two parallel universes for Big Tobacco” ~ Snus smuggling plummets after nicotine pouch law reform ~ The Smokefree Partnership Celebrates Driving Users Back to Cigarettes ~ Snatching Defeat from the Jaws of Victory? ~ Study: Flavored Vape Bans Increase Cigarette Sales ~ Hungary Ignores Science ~ UKVIA Launching New Sustainability Approach ~ Smoke Gets in Their Eyes: How the Liberals’ Anti-Tobacco Crusade Worsens Smokers’ Health ~ Star Power ~ Separating Nicotine from Tobacco: A Public Health Story for India’s Amrit Kaal ~ The Portuguese Government jeopardizes smoking cessation efforts ~ A leaked report from the European Commission questions EU smoke-free goals ~ Allison Boughner Chats To Ecigclick!! ~ Banning disposable vapes is a gift for black market criminals ~ Vaping is unhealthy, but banning it in Arizona could hurt teens more
THR Summit calls for alignment of communication to fight against misinformation
Watipaso Mzungu, NYASA Times
Delegates to the 6th Summit on Tobacco Harm Reduction (THR) have called for the alignment of communication to fight misinformation on THR, stressing that people need to get clear and strong messages about the scientific evidence on the benefits of harm reduction products in order to counteract the misinformation launched by opposing parts.
Harm reduction policies can result in RM1.1bil annual savings, says think tank
Free Malaysia Today
A think tank estimates that over RM1.1 billion in government spending can be saved annually if harm reduction policies in public health and transportation are adopted.
The Center for Market Education (CME) also said switching just 1% of the smoking population to alternative products could potentially result in a RM2.61 billion gain in productivity, or 0.16% of Malaysia’s GDP
Response to Emeritus Professor Simon Chapman AO, “Two parallel universes for Big Tobacco”
Colin Mendelsohn, colinmendelsohn.com.au
EMERITUS PROFESSOR SIMON CHAPMAN AO recently wrote a blog titled “Two parallel universes for Big Tobacco”, in which he dismissed the aspirations of some tobacco companies to transition away from combustible cigarettes to reduced risk nicotine products. He also misrepresented and derided my statements on nicotine and vaping. This is my response to correct the record.
Opposition to industry transformation
Professor Chapman’s attitude to the tobacco industry remains stuck in the tobacco wars of the past. There is no doubt the tobacco industry has an appalling record of selling addictive and deadly products, lying about the health effects of smoking and obstructing tobacco control.
Snus smuggling plummets after nicotine pouch law reform
YLE NEWS
Finnish Customs seized around 700 kilos of snus between January and September this year, compared to the some 3,500 kilos taken from smugglers during the same period 2022.
While snus, a smokeless tobacco product, is prohibited in all member states of the European Union except Sweden, the import of small amounts to Finland for personal use is allowed. However, bringing in large amounts, selling or passing on snus is illegal.
The Smokefree Partnership Celebrates Driving Users Back to Cigarettes
Joseph Hart, The Daily Pouch
Smokefree Partnership was in a celebratory mood this week. Belgium banned nicotine pouches as of October 1st. “Great news“, according to the coalition of anti-smoking NGOs.
Understandably, there was some pushback. Limiting citizens’ access to harm-reduction products isn’t something to celebrate if you want people to stop smoking. However, more perversely, if you are serious about being “smoke-free”, then you should be at least curious about smokeless products, like nicotine pouches.
Snatching Defeat from the Jaws of Victory?
Clive Bates, Tobacco Reporter
There are so many genuinely terrible ways to regulate combustible tobacco and smoke-free nicotine products that achieving one of the less terrible ways is a triumph. Unlike the United States, the European Union hasn’t imposed gigantic regulatory burdens that choke the life out of all but the largest companies, relentlessly favoring tobacco majors over their smaller rivals.
Unlike Australia, the EU pulled back from regulating vapes as if they were medicines. Australia was once a leader in tobacco control, but now it has become a chaotic fiasco of sluggish declines in smoking and a massive black market. Despite the prohibition campaigns of the World Health Organization, the EU has resisted most forms of prohibition, though with the inexplicable exception of snus. To state the obvious, prohibition doesn’t cause banned products to disappear; it merely removes law-abiding suppliers and hands the residual market to criminals and unregulated informal traders.
Study: Flavored Vape Bans Increase Cigarette Sales
Jim McDonald, Vaping 360
New research funded by the FDA and the National Institutes of Health (NIH) shows that flavored vape bans lead to decreased vape sales and increased cigarette sales. The study’s authors say that for every 0.7 mL vape pod not sold because of flavor restrictions, 15 cigarettes take its place.
Seven U.S. states and nearly 400 local governments have passed laws restricting the sales of non-tobacco (and sometimes menthol) vape flavors. The adoption of such laws has been a major goal of tobacco control organizations and their biggest funder, Bloomberg Philanthropies.
Crime against retail sector in NZ has skyrocketed. Shame my 2021 scientific papers on this #blacklisted by @minhealthnz Some injuries could have been prevented at least if #FreeSpeech was allowed @NZFreeSpeech https://t.co/YUS0j24KyC
— Prof Marewa Glover (@MarewaGlover) October 4, 2023
Two From Dave Cross, Planet Of The Vapes
Hungary Ignores Science
The Hungarian Government issued a statement on its anti-smoking measures, dismissing the significant harm reduction benefits of vaping and other smokeless alternatives. This stance not only denies globally accepted scientific consensus but also appears to deliberately undermine the proven success of countries like Sweden in their harm reduction initiatives, according to the World Vapers’ Alliance.
UKVIA Launching New Sustainability Approach
The UK Vaping Industry Association (UKVIA) is set to launch a new vape recycling information hub and Sustainable Vaping Week. The new initiatives are being introduced to address the throwaway behaviours of vapers and support full industry compliance with environmental regulations.
Ian Irvine, C2C Journal
How did you celebrate World No Tobacco Day 2023? In Ottawa, the federal government marked the occasion with an announcement that new health warnings will soon be required for all cigarettes legally purchased in Canada. Until now, smokers have had to make do with grotesque photos of diseased lungs and other cadaverous body parts on their cigarette packages. Starting next year, however, printed slogans such as “Poison in every puff” will be mandated on each individual cigarette. This regulatory innovation “will make it virtually impossible to avoid health warnings,” Health Canada declared in its press release. Carolyn Bennett, then-federal Minister for Mental Health and Addictions, called it a “bold step” for Canada, the first country in the world to take such action.
Editor Note: PDF: Smoke Gets in Their Eyes_ How the Liberals’ Anti-Tobacco Crusade Worsens Smokers’ Health _ C2C Journal
Star Power
Cheryl K. Olson, Tobacco Reporter
Celebrity news sites have reported sightings of Sasha Obama, the daughter of the former president, smoking cigarettes. There she is, puffing with friends outside a glamourous Los Angeles party. And here, exhaling while exiting a luxury wellness spa. She makes no apparent attempt to evade the photographers.
No longer taboo, cigarettes are increasingly seen dangling from the lips of celebrities, on the streets and on-screen. Once-ubiquitous mentions of vaping as trendy and cool have gone up in smoke.
Dr. Sudhanahu Patwardhan, The Quint
Under India’s historic presidency, the G20 Summit held in early September received well-deserved acclaim, both domestically and internationally. India is increasingly being considered a major global player – politically, economically, and industrially.
India’s thorough preparation was evident in the 200 pre-summit meetings held across 50 cities, addressing wide-ranging issues from climate change to education.
Two From World Vapers’ Alliance
The Portuguese Government jeopardizes smoking cessation efforts
The Portuguese government is discussing a new draft law regulating tobacco use that will detrimentally damage Portugal’s efforts to curb smoking. The government is currently transcribing the EU delegated act of the Tobacco Products Directive into the national legislation on heated tobacco products, including several provisions on vaping that have not been a part of the original delegated act.
These measures represent a step backward in the adoption of an open and evidence-based approach to alternative nicotine products and will discourage smokers from switching to this safer alternative pushing many vapers back to smoking, says World Vapers’ Alliance.
Earlier this week, a leaked report from the European Commission circulated among the Members of the European Parliament with the shocking position of the EU legislators on the future of harm reduction in Europe. According to the post on X from MEP Charlie Weimers, “there are two notable writings: praise for how successful the snus ban has been and a recommendation that the EU should extend the snus ban to the tobacco-free white snus (nicotine pouches).” The report, that is supposed to be officially presented to the Members of the EU Parliament later this week, gravely diminishes the Swedish smoke-free success and threatens lives of many former and current smokers in the EU, says World Vapers’ Alliance.
Allison Boughner Chats To Ecigclick!!
Michelle, EcigClick
In our latest “THR Superstar” interview I got to chat with the lovely Allison Boughner to find out more about her and her views on THR (Tobacco Harm Reduction).
Allison is the Vice President of the AVM (American Vapor Manufacturers Association), the President of the SCVA (South Carolina Vapor Association) and also a Fellow of the WVA (World Vapers’ Alliance).
Banning disposable vapes is a gift for black market criminals
Martin Cullip, CapX
The Government’s rumoured plan to ban disposable vapes under the guise of protecting children is nothing short of a spectacular misstep.
Let’s be clear: the imperative of safeguarding our children from harm is understandable. However, the decision to ban disposable vapes is a classic example of heavy-handed, knee-jerk regulation that threatens to ignite a new black market right under the government’s nose. Much like the ban on vaping products in Australia, which only served to create a thriving underground market, the UK’s ban is destined for the same disastrous outcome.
Vaping is unhealthy, but banning it in Arizona could hurt teens more
Peter Clark, AZ Central
The law of unintended consequences makes e-cigarette bans a bad idea.
Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes in September joined 32 other AGs in calling for the Federal Drug Administration to impose stronger regulations shielding teens from the dangers of vaping.
The coalition recommended a ban on non-tobacco flavored e-cigarettes, believing the use entices adolescents to pick up the habit.
Reducing youth vaping is a laudable goal.
Visit Nicotine Science & Policy for more News from around the World