Vapers Digest 16th November
Monday’s News at a glance:
Alex Wodak’s Unfinished Challenge to Public Health ~ The Double Standard Behind the “False Promise” ~ The Week in Tobacco Harm Reduction ~ On Stupidity …in Tobacco Control? ~ Asia Pacific needs a WHO leader who listens, says CAPHRA ~ Events ~ See Opportunities ~ Two EU Dumpster Fires Come Crashing Down: Tobacco Products Directive and the Tobacco Taxation Directive ~ Michigan Adult Smoking Falls Nearly 50 Percent as Youth Vaping Declines ~ Rhode Island Youth Vaping Tumbles Nearly 60 Percent as Adult Smoking Hits Historic Low ~ Impacts of vaping on children and young people: a systematic review ~ Nicotine pouch users’ exposure to major toxicants closer to non-smokers’ levels, review finds ~ Quitting smoking: vaping helps without support, but twice as well with it ~ Powerful Trump Allies Aided a Chinese Vape Operation
Three From Alan Gorley
Alex Wodak’s Unfinished Challenge to Public Health
On 12 November 1986, a group of people in Sydney began openly providing sterile injecting equipment to people who injected drugs and collecting their used equipment. They were responding to an approaching catastrophe with something practical: a way to reduce the transmission of HIV.
The obstacle was that the law stood in their way.
The Double Standard Behind the “False Promise”
Public health arguments should become more convincing when examined closely. The Newsroom article by Janet Hoek, Lori Leigh and Andrew Waa becomes less convincing. Its starting point is reasonable: nicotine pouches cannot be promised as a solution to illicit tobacco. But what follows is an argument built on conflated outcomes, selective scepticism and a standard of success that the authors do not apply to their own preferred policies.
The Week in Tobacco Harm Reduction
Welcome to The Week in Tobacco Harm Reduction – my weekly look at the evidence, decisions and debates shaping how people move away from smoking. I bring together developments worth your time, examine what the evidence actually shows, and ask what they mean for people whose lives are affected.
Charles A. Gardner, PhD, Medium
December 1942, Berlin: Pastor and resistence leader Dietrich Bonhoeffer, pondered how a whole country full of educated and good people, poets, thinkers and scientists, could go so far off-the-rails. The essay he wrote carries a powerful lesson for today’s public health controversies.
Asia Pacific needs a WHO leader who listens, says CAPHRA
NE Loucas, Coalition of Asia Pacific Harm Reduction Advocates (CAPHRA)
Seven candidates for WHO Director-General face member states in Geneva from 18 November. The Coalition of Asia Pacific Tobacco Harm Reduction Advocates (CAPHRA) wants each to say how they would listen to doctors, patients and consumers. CAPHRA takes no position on any candidate.
The call follows a petition from Indonesian medical professors and anti-corruption groups asking the WHO Executive Board to reject Indonesia’s nominee, Health Minister Budi Gunadi Sadikin.
Two EU Dumpster Fires Come Crashing Down: Tobacco Products Directive and the Tobacco Taxation Directive
Thomas Frohnert, Firebreak
To save face, the European Parliament hastily approved the ambitious “European Plan Against Cancer” (BECA report) on November 12th, including demands for bans on flavorings and strict restrictions on e-cigarettes and nicotine pouches. But let’s not be fooled: this parliamentary report is a so-called own-initiative report (INI). Legally speaking, it’s just printed paper without any legal force. A pure smokescreen.

A look back at how things have moved on or otherwise…
E-Cig Summit Roundup 2018
James Dunworth – Ashtray Blog
I still can’t believe that we’ve reached the 6th E-Cig Summit – it doesn’t seem so long ago that the first one was held! This is very much a non-commercial conference, with sales pitches banned (hooray!) and proficient speakers who are good at lightening up some challenging topics with a bit of humour. Add that to superb organisation and it all makes for a great conference.
Youth vaping & the dangers of over-reaction
A letter to the FDA – Clive Bates
Letter from Iowa Attorney General Miller and others, including me, to Scott Gottlieb, FDA Commissioner. See PDF at the link below:
Re: Youth tobacco and nicotine use – proportionate and responsible reaction
This is a letter and 7-page briefing to set out issues with youth vaping and to caution against over-reaction. For the fully referenced version, please see the PDF at the link above. The main text is below.
Visit Nicotine Science & Policy for more News from around the World








