Vapers Digest 18th March

Wednesday’s News at a glance:
Parliamentary Matters ~ Farsalinos Reviews Pouch Evidence ~ VPZ Calls For Strong Enforcement ~ UKVIA Responds to Glasgow Fire ~ The Youth-Smoking Collapse Nobody Wants to Talk About ~ The public-health crisis that Democrats won’t see ~ The Gateway That Never Appeared ~ Teen Vaping in NSW: What the Data Really Shows ~ The Question Warsaw Still Asks ~ Europe’s Vaping Black Market Is Booming. Politicians Need to Wake Up. ~ Researchers fuming over EU health commissioner’s nicotine misinformation ~ Experts slam EU commissioner’s ‘hazardous’ claims about alternatives to cigarettes ~ Retracted vaping study shows the real danger of misinformation in nicotine debate ~ YouTuber powers electric car using 500 discarded vape batteries ~ How FDA Can Better Align Its Draft Guidance on Flavored ENDS with the Tobacco Control Act’s APPH Mandate ~ Exclusive: Glas says FDA-authorized G2 vape includes age-gating technology ~ If Kenya bans flavours, cigarettes will win ~ New York Sheriff Pushes Back on Gov Hochul’s 75% ‘Bro Tax’ on Nicotine Pouches ~ Unraveling the FDA’s shortsighted ban on flavored vapes ~ Planned Denial | FDA’s Shifting Standards For Vape Authorization ~ How to Avoid Pitfalls in Observational E-Cigarette Health Research | #GFN25 Science Discussion
Four from Dave Cross, Planet of the Vapes
Parliamentary Matters
In her last outing as Parliamentary Under-Secretary for Health and Social Care, as part of debate on National Wellbeing Indicators, Ashley Dalton MP was told off by the speaker for not answering a question. Yes, that’s right, the Department of Health and Revolving Doors has ushered in yet another Under-Secretary for Health. Dalton also fielded some questions from Ruth Jones MP, Chair of the Welsh Affairs Committee.
Farsalinos Reviews Pouch Evidence
Dr Konstantinos Farsalinos has produced a major review which finds that nicotine pouches could be safest alternative to tobacco use yet for smokers. The new scientific review reveals that oral nicotine pouches show all the signs of being most effective method of helping smokers to give up deadly cigarettes.
VPZ Calls For Strong Enforcement
VPZ, the UK’s largest specialist vape retailer, has acknowledged the passage of the Tobacco and Vapes Bill through the House of Lords, marking a significant milestone in the United Kingdom’s public health and regulatory framework for nicotine products. The retailer told Planet of the Vapes that it has long supported responsible retail standards, strong compliance systems and effective enforcement remain essential to maintaining consumer safety and public confidence in regulated vaping products.
UKVIA Responds to Glasgow Fire
The UK Vaping Industry Association (UKVIA) has responded to the vape shop fire in Glasgow and said its thoughts are with everyone affected. The trade body has also sent a letter to the National Fire Chiefs Council, offering to work closely with them to identify any lessons to be learnt that arise from the incident.
The Youth-Smoking Collapse Nobody Wants to Talk About
Martin Cullip, Filter
For more than a decade, one of the most persistent claims in the tobacco control echo chamber has been that nicotine vapes act as a “gateway” to smoking for young people. But the gap between the claim and the observable reality keeps growing wider.
The latest example is from the annual National Youth Tobacco Survey (NYTS) in the United States. The 2025 results, released on March 4, show that youth use of tobacco and nicotine products continues to decline.
The public-health crisis that Democrats won’t see
Marc Gunther, The Best Laid Plans
Democrats like to think of themselves as the party that embraces science, innovation and evidence-based policy. On issues such as climate change and vaccines, they’re mostly right.
That’s not the case when it comes to smoking. Cigarette smoking kills about 480,000 Americans a year. That’s more deaths than the CDC attributed to COVID-19 in 2021, the worst year of the epidemic.
Democrats are making the problem worse.
Two From Alan Gore
The Gateway That Never Appeared
For more than a decade, one of the most persistent claims in tobacco control has been that vaping would act as a gateway to cigarette smoking among teenagers. The idea was simple and alarming. Young people would experiment with e-cigarettes, become addicted to nicotine, and eventually graduate to traditional cigarettes. According to this theory, vaping threatened to undo decades of progress in reducing youth smoking. But the real-world data are telling a very different story.
Teen Vaping in NSW: What the Data Really Shows
The report “Turning the Tide on NSW Teen Vaping” from the Cancer Council NSW presents itself as evidence that Australia’s strict pharmacy-only vaping model is working and that youth vaping is declining. But when the data and methodology are examined closely, the conclusions are far less convincing than the headline claims suggest.
The Question Warsaw Still Asks
Claudio Teixeira, Disobedient Margins
The deadliest nicotine product ever invented remains legal, visible, and routine. It is there in convenience stores, in the crumpled packs carried in a pocket, in the break during the workday, on the corner, in the habit itself. Almost everywhere, the combustible cigarette remains so readily available that its chemical violence nearly dissolves into the landscape.
The paradox requires no rhetoric. Around it, however, the language of prudence shifts in tone. Nicotine products that are substantially less dangerous, though backed by different kinds and degrees of evidence, such as vapes, snus, nicotine pouches, and heated tobacco, circulate in many countries under a regime of suspicion denser than the one reserved for the cigarette itself.
Michael Landl, World Vapers’ Alliance
A new study by the Fraunhofer Institute and MRU GmbH has put some hard numbers on something vapers have known for a while: the illegal vape market in Europe is massive and growing fast. According to the research, nearly half of all vaping products consumed across the EU are now traded irregularly, worth around €6.6 billion. If nothing changes, that figure could hit €11 billion by 2030.
This should be a wake-up call. But judging by the direction of policy in several countries, it is not landing.
Researchers fuming over EU health commissioner’s nicotine misinformation
Snusforumet
A group of leading European academics and medical researchers has publicly challenged what they describe as “false and misleading” statements by EU Health Commissioner Olivér Várhelyi about the risks of smoke-free nicotine products.
In an open letter to European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, 23 experts from more than a dozen countries warn that the Commissioner’s claims could undermine public health policy and mislead millions of smokers across Europe.
Experts slam EU commissioner’s “hazardous’ claims about alternatives to cigarettes
Michaela Koubová, EU Perspectives
Misinformation that could cost the lives of thousands of Europeans — 23 independent European scientists and public policy experts on tobacco and nicotine describe statements by Olivér Várhelyi, European health commissioner, on the risks of nicotine alternatives. The experts say so in a letter they addressed to Ursula von der Leyen, European Commission president.
The statements constitute the spread of misinformation. We urge you to take steps to prevent further loss of trust in the European Union,” the letter reads.

Retracted vaping study shows the real danger of misinformation in nicotine debate
Smoke Free Sweden
A scientific paper claiming to link vaping with cancer has been formally retracted by the Journal of Cancer Policy after editors found serious flaws that undermined its conclusions.
The journal withdrew the review after identifying major problems with the study’s design, including inconsistencies in the evidence base, misclassification of research and conclusions that were not supported by the data.
Smoke Free Sweden says the episode highlights a growing problem in the global tobacco debate: the rapid spread of unreliable claims about safer nicotine alternatives.
YouTuber powers electric car using 500 discarded vape batteries
Tim Hong, Clearing The Air
A UK engineer and YouTuber has powered a small electric car using a battery pack made from hundreds of discarded vape batteries, highlighting the hidden energy still left inside many disposable devices.
Chris Doel, a 27-year-old software and electronics engineer at Jaguar Land Rover, dismantled lithium batteries from around 500 disposable vapes and used them to power a 2007 G-Wiz micro-electric car.
The unusual project, which he documented on his YouTube channel, allowed the tiny vehicle to reach a top speed of almost 40mph and travel roughly 18 miles on a single charge.
How FDA Can Better Align Its Draft Guidance on Flavored ENDS with the Tobacco Control Act’s APPH Mandate
Azim Chowdhury, The Continuum of Risk
As discussed in our earlier post, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s (FDA) new draft guidance on flavored electronic nicotine delivery system (ENDS) products represents a meaningful effort to provide additional clarity about the Agency’s evidentiary expectations for premarket tobacco product applications (PMTAs). That clarity is welcome. At the same time, the draft guidance would better align with the statutory mandate in Section 910 of the Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act (TCA) if it more clearly recognized that (1) comparative-efficacy evidence as framed in the marketing denial orders issued by FDA to date cannot be treated as an across-the-board requirement for every flavored ENDS application; and (2) when comparative-efficacy analysis is relevant, the more meaningful public-health comparator is combustible cigarettes, not tobacco-flavored ENDS.
Exclusive: Glas says FDA-authorized G2 vape includes age-gating technology
2Firsts
Glas Inc. has confirmed to 2Firsts that the device granted marketing authorization by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) on March 12 (U.S. Eastern Time) is its Glas G2 platform and that it incorporates age-gating technology, meaning that, based on currently public information, the FDA has authorized the first electronic nicotine delivery system (ENDS) product confirmed to include such a feature.
If Kenya bans flavours, cigarettes will win
Joseph Magero, Capital Business
In the ongoing debate about the use of flavours in nicotine products, one voice always seems to go unheard. That is the voice of the adult smokers who are desperate to quit their deadly habit.
Evidence, including Kenyan surveys, shows non-tobacco flavours help smokers switch to less risky alternatives.
Outlawing flavours, as proposed in the Tobacco Bill currently being discussed in parliament, will simply trap those smokers with no alternatives to traditional cigarettes, or drive them to unregulated products in the illicit market.
New York Sheriff Pushes Back on Gov Hochul’s 75% ‘Bro Tax’ on Nicotine Pouches
Nick R. Hamilton, Slay News
The top law enforcement official in Erie County is warning New York lawmakers that Democrat Gov. Kathy Hochul’s proposed 75% “bro tax” on nicotine pouches could backfire.
Erie County Sheriff John Garcia warns that the move will end up driving more sales underground rather than reducing use.
The sheriff, who represents Hochul’s home county, sent a letter to state legislative leaders urging them to reject the proposal.
Garcia is arguing that New York’s existing approach to tobacco taxation has already produced a thriving illicit market.
PDF Unraveling the FDA’s shortsighted ban on flavored vapes
Washington Post
The Food and Drug Administration recently signaled that it’s planning to let e-cigarette companies sell a broader range of flavors in the United States. It’s a welcome change, but the FDA isn’t going nearly far enough.Illegal vapes began flooding into the U.S. after the enactment of the 2020 ban, which affected all vapes except tobacco- and menthol-flavored products.
Planned Denial | FDA’s Shifting Standards For Vape Authorization
Brent Stafford, Regulator Watch
Nicotine regulation in the United States has entered a strange phase.
The FDA says it’s protecting public health. But in practice, it’s blocking safer nicotine products while leaving deadly cigarettes on the market.
In Part 1 of this RegWatch special, independent scientist Dr. Ian Fearon breaks down the mechanics behind that contradiction. From the overwhelming volume of PMTA applications to the agency’s shifting standards and mass denials, Fearon exposes a regulatory system struggling to keep pace with innovation.
How to Avoid Pitfalls in Observational E-Cigarette Health Research | #GFN25 Science Discussion
Global Forum on Nicotine
Dr Arielle Selya presents a review of the common flaws in observational research on e-cigarette use and discusses the impact that these flaws have on study conclusions. Dr Selya offers suggestion on how future studies in the field could be improved. #GFN25ScienceLab
A look back at how things have moved on or otherwise…
Prohibition, problem gambling …
And playing with words – Christopher Snowdon
Australia’s umpteenth attempt to ban e-cigarettes has been warmly applauded by the renowned wowser and imbecile Simon Chapman. Nicotine-containing vapes have always been illegal in Australia. Importation of these products for personal use was banned a few years ago and now the government is banning all e-cigarettes regardless of whether they contain nicotine or not.
Tangible Benefits of Social Drugs?
Alan Beard
A simplistic and relatively shallow series of muses here, prompted by repeated commentary from naysayers, particularly in reference to nicotine.
Social Drugs I shall confine to just three varieties, although many more exist. I shall discuss Caffeine, Alcohol, Nicotine but not include another very popular Social Drug :-Cannabis, for whatever reasoning.
Visit Nicotine Science & Policy for more News from around the World






